Bechoros 60
Summary
- Today's *daf yomi* dedicates the *shiur* to לעילוי נשמת Mr. Harry H. Baron עליו השלום צבי חייקל בן אהרן זאב עליו השלום and learns מסכת בכורות דף ס', beginning on דף נ"ט עמוד ב'. Rava’s rule of מניין הראוי establishes that once animals begin exiting for מעשר בהמה in a properly countable way, those already counted remain counted even if the full ten cannot ultimately be completed, because יעבור ולא שכבר עבר. The *shiur* applies this rule to multiple cases involving a pen with two doors and different exit sequences, then develops further halakhot about handling fifteen and nineteen animals and reconciling *beraitot* through a case where the tenth is “fit” for either side. The final *mishnah* and ensuing *gemara* analyze mistakes in counting, simultaneous exits, the sanctity of ninth, tenth, and eleventh, and whether sanctity follows the spoken count or the actual animal-number, including implications for תמורה and the rule that עשירי מאליו קדוש.
- Today's דף יומי is dedicated לעילוי נשמת a great תורה and OU benefactor Mr. Harry H. Baron עליו השלום צבי חייקל בן אהרן זאב עליו השלום. Today's שיעור is מסכת בכורות דף ס' and begins on דף נ"ט עמוד ב' 16 lines from the bottom. Rava teaches מניין הראוי, that when counting animals for מעשר בהמה, once one begins counting properly and then later cannot complete ten, the animals already counted remain counted and do not require restarting, because יעבור ולא שכבר עבר.
- Rava applies מניין הראוי to three cases of fourteen lambs in a pen with two doors. Rava rules that when six exit one door and four exit the other and four remain, the remaining four complete ten only if they exit the door of the six so that six plus four yields ten, and then one is taken as מעשר while the other four from the other door still must join another *goren*. The חזון איש explains that the first six are protected by מניין הראוי because when they exited there were still eight inside, while the four that exit the other door lack מניין הראוי because only four remain to combine, and he adds that combining can depend on how the counting is started if the last four exit a different door.
- Rava rules that when four exit first and then six exit the other door and four remain, the first four are מניין הראוי because ten remain, and the six are also מניין הראוי because they still can combine with the remaining four, so both groups can be פטור. Rava rules that the last four are resolved only if they exit with the six to create ten, while if they exit with the first four they are not a מניין הראוי and must still join another *goren*.
- Rava rules that when four exit one door and then four exit the other and six remain, all fourteen are taken care of if the final six exit through one door to make ten with one of the earlier fours. Rashi, as explained by the אמרי יושר, reads the failure case as the last six splitting three and three and exiting simultaneously through two doors so that neither side reaches ten and the last six are not a מניין הראוי, while the two groups of four remain פטור and the last six must join another *goren*.
- The *gemara* asks מאי קא משמע לן since Rava already taught the principle of מניין הראוי. The *gemara* answers that one might think Rava applies מניין הראוי only in a certain setup where ten would have been completed but for an external event, while in these two-door cases the outcome is uncertain and is a ספק מניין הראוי דחזי להכא ודחזי להכא. The *gemara* teaches that Rava still applies מניין הראוי even in such uncertain configurations.
- Rava teaches that if one has חמישה עשר טלאים, one should not say אברור עשרה והכניסם לדיר ואטול מהם אחד ושאר פטורים. Rava rules that one must put all fifteen into the pen, count out ten for the procedure, take the tenth as מעשר, and the remaining five מצטרפין לגורן אחר.
- Rashi presents two *chidushim* in Rava, that one must bring all fifteen into the pen even though a remainder is expected, and that the remaining five retain a strong חיוב because the process began with them present. The חזון איש says that if one did select ten anyway, בדיעבד it would be fine, and the רוגאטשאווער explains Rashi that the remaining five are treated as טבל until five more are found to complete another count. The *shiur* adds that this applies only while other animals can be found within the same year, because once the year ends the rules of חדש וישן prevent combining.
- A *beraita* supports Rava’s fifteen-animal rule, repeating that one must not select ten and exempt the remainder, but must count ten from the full group and leave the remaining five obligated to join another *goren*. The *gemara* then presents a different *beraita* about תשעה עשר טלאים that also forbids selecting ten, yet rules that after counting ten and taking one, the remaining nine are פטורים, creating a contradiction.
- Rav Huna bar Ḥinina resolves the contradiction before Rava בריגלא by interpreting the nineteen-animal case as a pen with two doors where nine exit one door and nine exit the other. The tenth animal is described as דהאי חד חזי להכא ולהכא, so it can serve as the tenth for either group, making both nines fall under מניין הראוי and rendering the remainder פטור. The *shiur* emphasizes the major *chidush* that one animal is attributed to both groups as a tenth, and notes that the פוסקים discuss this concept in contexts such as fulfilling two obligations with one act, including questions about one *kaddish* for two parents and one fast coinciding with a *taanit tzibbur*.
- The מנחת יצחק is cited as rejecting an attempt to extend this idea to counting one person as the tenth for two separate *minyanim* in two rooms, because a *minyan* requires a unified listening and answering to one *shaliach tzibbur* and one person cannot function in two simultaneous prayer groups. Rav Naḥman bar Yitzḥak praises Rav Huna bar Ḥinina by saying זכאי אמיה דרב הונא בר חורא דשנא ליה שמעתתא בריגלא כשמעתיה, and the *shiur* cites Rav Yitzchak Zilberstein that the phrase highlights the mother’s role in raising such a תלמיד חכם. The *shiur* also derives a ruling that a son may allow his father to drive him between שיעורים because a parent’s greatest pride is enabling a child’s Torah teaching.
- The last *mishnah* states that if two animals exit together and the owner mistakenly counts them as one, then the subsequent ninth and tenth designations become מקולקלים. The *shiur* presents that the ראשונים explain מקולקלים as arising from failure to ask how to count when two exit together, and they also state that the usual rules for a mistaken ninth, tenth, and eleventh do not apply in this scenario, so the affected animals must wait to become בעלי מום.
- The *mishnah* rules that if one calls the ninth “tenth,” the tenth “ninth,” and the eleventh “tenth,” all three are sanctified with distinct laws: the ninth is eaten only after becoming blemished, the tenth is מעשר בהמה, and the eleventh is offered as a קרבן שלמים. The *shiur* states that שלמים differs from מעשר in requirements such as חזה ושוק with תנופה and gifts to כהנים, סמיכה, נסכים, and blood application of שתים שהן ארבע versus the single application for מעשר.
- The *mishnah* records a dispute whether the eleventh that becomes a שלמים makes תמורה. Rabbi Meir holds ועושה תמורה because it is a true שלמים, while Rabbi Yehuda argues וכי יש תמורה עושה תמורה because it arises as a תמורה-like extension and a תמורה cannot create another תמורה. Rabbi Meir answers that if it were truly a תמורה of מעשר, it would not be offered, so it must be a real שלמים that can generate תמורה.
- The *mishnah* rules that if one calls the ninth “tenth,” calls the tenth correctly as “tenth,” and calls the eleventh “tenth,” then אין אחד עשר מקודש. The *mishnah* sets the principle that כל שלא נעקר שם עשירי הימנו, when the name “tenth” was not uprooted from the true tenth, the mistaken eleventh does not acquire the sanctity of a שלמים.
- The *shiur* notes that the first letter of the tractate’s first *mishnah* is ה and the last letter of the final *mishnah* is שין, forming שה. The *shiur* ties this to the tractate’s recurring focus on sheep in בכור בהמה, פטר חמור תפדה בשה, and מעשר בהמה, and connects it to יציאת מצרים and the message that everything belongs to Hashem.
- Rabbi Yoḥanan teaches that when animals exit זוגות זוגות or כנתרין כנתרין, עשירי למניינו הוא קדוש. Rav Mari explains this as sanctity following the spoken counting unit, so the fifth pair can be “tenth,” while Rav Kahana explains that sanctity follows the actual tenth animal regardless of how one counts.
- The *gemara* challenges from the *mishnah* of two animals exiting together, and answers that Rabbi Yoḥanan’s rule according to Rav Mari applies only when one intentionally sets up counting in pairs, not when animals happen to exit together unintentionally. The *gemara* then cites a *beraita* about counting backwards, and addresses how the “tenth” can still be קדוש when called “one” by explaining that people from פרסא count in that manner. The *shiur* explains that because עשירי מאליו קדוש, the required language-threshold is lower, and an unconventional counting expression can suffice as long as it is a recognized mode of speech.
- A *beraita* derives from וכל מעשר בקר וצאן כל אשר יעבר תחת השבט העשירי יהיה קדש that one who calls the ninth “tenth,” the tenth “ninth,” and the eleventh “tenth” makes all three sanctified. The *beraita* rejects extending this to eight and twelve by stating that the tenth is קדוש only בסמוך and therefore its “error-sanctity” also applies only to adjacent animals.
- The *gemara* cites another *beraita* and identifies it with רבי אלעזר ברבי שמעון, who holds לעולם אין אחד עשר קדוש until specific silence or non-error conditions occur regarding the ninth. The explanation links to רבי יהודה’s view that טעות מעשר תמורה and to the father’s view that אין תמורה חוזרת ותמורה, so a double-error structure would amount to an ineffective “double תמורה.”
- Rava rules that if two animals exit at the ninth and one is called ninth and the other tenth, then עשירי וחולין מעורבין זה בזה and one must wait until both become בעלי מום. Rava rules that if both are called “tenth” at the ninth point, then עשירי ותשיעי מעורבין זה בזה and the ninth takes on the mistaken ninth’s sanctity.
- Rava rules that if two animals exit at the tenth and both are called “tenth,” then עשירי ואחד עשר מעורבים זה בזה and both are treated with the stringencies of שלמים. Rava rules that if they are called “eleventh” and “tenth,” then עשירי וחולין מעורבים זה בזה. The *gemara* explains that Rava teaches that when animals exit together and both are called “tenth,” both become sanctified even though the true tenth was not stripped of its title, because simultaneous exit with a doubled “tenth” creates the halakhic status of error-sanctification.
Suggestions


