Arachin - Daf 2
- הכל מעריכין ונערכין
This מסכת discusses "ערכין", pledges to give the Biblically fixed value of a Jew, based on their gender and age, to hekdesh. The first Mishnah begins: הכל מעריכין – anyone can pledge an erech-vow, ונערכין – and be the subject of an erech-vow (i.e., any person’s ערך-value can be pledged), נודרין – [anyone] can pledge to give another’s worth (i.e., their personal value on the slave market), ונידרין – and can be the subject of a pledge for their own worth: Kohanim, Leviim, Yisroelim, women, and slaves. One cannot pledge the ערך of a טומטום or אנדרוגינוס, because ערכין are only for someone who is identifiably male or female. A חרש, שוטה, and קטן cannot pledge ערכין or נדרים, because they lack דעת – mental competence. The inclusive term "הכל" מעריכין comes to include מופלא סמוך לאיש – an articulate [minor] who is approaching adulthood (within a year of becoming a גדול), who can also pledge an erech-vow. The inclusive term "הכל נערכין" comes to include מנוול ומוכה שחין – one who is repulsive or afflicted with boils, who has no market value. Although the passuk says "נדר בערכך", linking nedarim with ערכין, we do not say כל שאינו בדמים אינו בערכין – any person who cannot be a subject for vows of value cannot be a subject for erech-vows, because "נפשות" – living beings implies כל דהו – anyone living, even without market value.
- Machlokes if a יורש performs semichah and makes תמורה
The Gemara proceeds to explain the inclusive term "הכל" in many Mishnayos. The term "הכל סומכין" – everyone leans on their korban comes to include יורש – an heir who inherited a korban, and "הכל ממירין" – all can substitute chullin animals for korbanos comes to include יורש – an heir. Both these rulings disagree with Rebbe Yehudah, who said: יורש אינו סומך – an heir does not perform semichah on a korban he inherited, and יורש אינו מימר – an heir cannot effect temurah. Rebbe Yehudah darshens that one only performs semichah on "קרבנו" – his own sacrifice, ולא קרבן אביו – and not his father’s sacrifice, because it is not considered his own. ויליף תחלת הקדש מסוף הקדש – He then derives the beginning of hekdesh from the end of hekdesh (i.e., temurah, where the second animal receives kedushah, is derived from semichah, which is performed just before shechitah): just as a יורש does not perform semichah, he also cannot effect temurah. The Rabbonon darshen "המר ימיר" – substitute he will substitute to include a יורש, and then derive סוף הקדש (semichah) from תחילת הקדש (temurah) to teach that even a יורש performs semichah.
- The inclusion of "הכל" regarding sukkah, lulav, tzitzis, tefillin, etc.
The Gemara continues to analyze the term "הכל" in many Mishnayos:
• "הכל חייבין בסוכה" – “All are obligated in the mitzvah to dwell in a sukkah” comes to include קטן שאינו צריך לאמו – a minor who does not need his mother.
• "הכל" written by lulav comes to include קטן היודע לנענע – a minor who knows how to wave a lulav.
• "הכל" written by ציצית comes to include קטן היודע להתעטף – a minor who knows how to wrap himself with a tallis.
• "הכל" written by tefillin comes to include קטן היודע לשמור תפלין – a minor who knows how to guard the kedushah of tefillin.
• "הכל" written by ראייה, the mitzvah to appear in the עזרה on the three רגלים, either comes to include מי שחציו עבד וחציו בן חורין – someone who is half-slave and half-freeman, someone who was lame on the first day of the רגל (and exempt from ראייה) but was healed on the second day, or someone who is blind in one eye.
• "הכל" written by שופר comes to include קטן שהגיע לחינוך – a minor who has reached the age of training.
Suggestions


